Writer's identity removed from Taylor Swift 'TTPD' album review due to 'threats of violence'

Paste magazine removed the writer's name from their review of Taylor Swift's album "The Tortured Poets Department" due to violent threats received after a previous album review. The publication stated, "No byline on this review because the writer faced threats of violence in 2019 over their review of 'Lover'." "We prioritize our staff's safety over the author's name in the article. The magazine's 'TTPD' review, labeled 'Paste Staff' instead of the writer's name, criticized Swift once again, questioning her songwriting skills on her 11th album."

The secret critic harshly criticized the Grammy winner's new single "Fortnight," with negative comments about producer Jack Antonoff's backing instrumental and the out-of-place vocal harmony provided by guest performer Post Malone. The review called the song opaque and suggested it was overwhelmed by its own flaws. The critic sarcastically questioned Swift's status as the songwriter of the century due to the temporary effects of her "miracle move-on drug", suggesting the need to prioritize reopening schools. The review mentioned that the singer, Swift, had her "worst lyricism to date" on her latest project. The critic added that she no longer feels challenged to be good, but acknowledged that "TTPD" will not be a net loss for her. "She will sell out arenas and get streams until she decides to quit (which is unlikely),” the review stated.

People discussed in the comments section of Paste Magazine's explanation if it was the right decision for the publication to remove the byline. “Readers will dislike if review only focuses on Taylor's personal life instead of her music. Improve," one person wrote. Another fan commented, "Where is the music review? This is gossip…" A third person added, "I don't agree with most of this review, but respect your decision to protect your staff." They shouldn't be hunted for their art opinion.

Despite Paste Magazine's review, "TTPD" made history with over 300 million Spotify streams in a day. Taylor Swift shaded Kim Kardashian and discussed her relationships with Joe Alwyn and Matty Healy on the project. She also delighted her fans by sharing a personal home video on Friday.